I asked Nick a simple question: What’s the worst thing on the planet for a bond portfolio? The answer was simple, too. Rising interest rates. That one force pulled a key thread in traditional portfolios, exposing a gap many investors did not see coming. When inflation jumped and interest rates surged, bonds suffered their worst year on record. Stocks struggled at the same time. The old 60/40 approach offered little shelter. I left that period convinced that most investors need to rethink their mix and add tools that can handle inflation and rate shocks.
How Rising Rates Hammer Bonds
Bonds are loans with fixed payments. When market rates rise, new bonds offer higher yields. The old bonds with lower coupons fall in price to compete. That link is tight and fast. The longer the maturity and the lower the coupon, the more prices swing when rates move. This is the duration at work. You do not need the math to feel the pain. You only needed to look at your statement in 2022.
Before that year, the worst modern year for bonds was 1994. Core bonds were down about 3%. In 2022, they fell about 13%. That was a four-times hit versus the prior worst year. The difference was the speed and size of the rate move. Inflation spiked. Central banks lifted policy rates fast to catch up. Long–and intermediate-term bonds reset at lower prices to reflect higher yields. Many investors saw losses in parts of their portfolio they once viewed as safe.
It was not only the price. The purpose of bonds in a balanced plan is twofold. They seek income, and they can offset equity drawdowns. In 2022, they did not play that second role. Stocks fell as the cost of money rose and margins came under pressure. Bonds fell as yields jumped. That double drawdown felt new to many, but the cause was clear. Inflation and rate shocks can hit both stocks and bonds at the same time.
“Rising interest rates… and you have no insurance policy.”
View this post on Instagram
The 60/40 Struggle
The classic 60/40 mix is not broken. It is built for a world where growth slows and inflation is stable or falling during equity selloffs. In those times, government bonds tend to rally as a flight to safety sets in. That is what gave balance to many past downturns. 2022 was different. Inflation was the driver, not a growth scare.
When inflation heats up, the central bank tightens monetary policy. Companies face higher input costs and higher discount rates. Profits and valuations compress. At the same time, bond prices slide as yields reprice. The result is a challenging year for both sides of the portfolio. The correlation between stocks and bonds approached 1. When that happens, the main benefit of diversification fades. You get the losses, not the cushion.
People often ask me if 60/40 is dead. No. But it is incomplete on its own. It can still do its job in many cycles. It just needs help facing an inflation spike. That is the lesson I want investors to keep in mind. If your only diversifiers are stocks and bonds, you are exposed when inflation drives the bus.
Correlation Risk and the Illusion of Safety
Diversification does not just mean many holdings. It means exposures that behave differently under stress. In 2022, many portfolios had many line items but still lacked proper balance. That is because those lines are all linked to the same core risks: growth and interest rates.
If stocks and bonds fall together, the math of diversification fails. The portfolio acts like one trade. That is the “correlations go to one” problem. It turns a balanced plan into a concentrated bet without warning. You think you have insurance, only to discover you do not. Real diversification needs return streams that can rise when inflation and rates rise. That is where alternatives come into play.
Why Alternatives Belong in More Portfolios
By alternatives, I mean assets and strategies that differ from traditional stocks and core bonds. The goal is simple. Add exposures that can help when inflation is sticky or rates jump. This is not about chasing the new thing. It is about filling a missing role: inflation and rate resilience.
I am not suggesting a wholesale shift. I am suggesting a thoughtful sleeve in a well-built plan. For most investors, that could be a modest share of the portfolio that plays defense when cash loses value and bonds suffer from rate moves. When built well, that sleeve can also seek returns when stocks do well. You want balance across many paths, not a bet on one path.
- Alternatives can provide returns not tied to stock market direction or bond yield levels.
- They may offer inflation sensitivity, rate hedges, or trend-following traits that thrive in shifting markets.
- Used in the right size, they can reduce drawdowns without giving up long-term growth.
What Fits the Job
There is no single “right” alternative. The mix should map to the risk you want to offset. Here are practical building blocks that many investors can access with liquid funds or ETFs. Each option has pros and cons. Sizing and risk control are key.
TIPS and Short Duration Bonds
Treasury Inflation-Protected Securities adjust principal with inflation. They can help when price levels rise. Short-duration bonds are less sensitive to rate moves. They can reset faster as yields change. Neither is a cure-all, but both help limit rate risk in the fixed income sleeve.
Commodities
Broad commodity funds hold futures across energy, metals, and agriculture. They tend to respond to inflation pressures. They can spike in supply shocks. They can also be volatile and face long flat periods. The role is to hedge inflation bursts, not to replace core holdings.
Real Assets
Real estate and infrastructure often link revenues to inflation through rents and contracts. Public REITs can be rate sensitive in the short run, but long-term cash flows may track inflation. Private vehicles introduce illiquidity and additional fees, which require careful review.
Managed Futures and Trend Strategies
These strategies follow price trends in global futures. They can go long or short across stocks, rates, currencies, and commodities. Their aim is to adapt when regimes shift. They often shine in inflation spikes and during sharp rate moves. They can also lag when markets are calm.
Floating-Rate Credit
Loans with floating coupons adjust as reference rates move. That reduces interest rate sensitivity. Credit risk remains, so spreads can widen in recessions. The fit is for investors who want less duration and can handle credit swings.
Option-Based Equity Strategies
Covered call or put-write funds seek income from option premiums. They can reduce equity volatility and add cash flow. They may lag in strong bull runs. They are tools for smoothing, not for beating the market at all times.
How to Put It Together
I build portfolios with roles in mind—growth, income, stability, and diversifiers. The first step is to define the problem you are trying to solve. If the gap is inflation or rate shock risk, pick tools that target it. Then size them so they matter without overwhelming the plan.
Practical steps I follow:
- Spell out objectives: Reduce drawdowns from inflation and rate spikes while keeping long-term return goals intact.
- Set a sleeve: A modest allocation to a mix of inflation-aware assets and strategies that react to trends.
- Avoid overlap: Make sure your choices truly add different risk drivers, not more of the same.
- Mind liquidity: Use liquid vehicles when you need flexibility. Be cautious with lockups.
- Watch fees and taxes: Higher costs can erode the value of diversification when sizing is small.
- Rebalance: Set rules to trim winners and add to laggards. Do not let the sleeve drift into a new core holding.
For many, a simple starting point could be upgrading the bond side with a blend of TIPS and short-duration, then adding a small slice of commodities and trend strategies. That mix hits inflation, rate, and correlation angles. It is not perfect. It is a step toward better balance.
Risk, Sizing, and Expectations
Alternatives are not magic. They can lose money. They will not always work. The aim is to improve the whole, not to hunt for a hero. Think of them as insurance you hope not to need every year. In years when inflation cools and stocks rally, this sleeve may look dull. That is fine. You hired it for a different job.
Sizing matters more than selection after a point. Too small, and the hedge does nothing in stress. Too large, and you may sacrifice long-term growth. The right size depends on your goals, time horizon, and the risks you want to address. Many investors find success with a measured approach and regular reviews.
What I Told Nick
During our conversation, I put it bluntly. Inflation pushed rates up. Rates crushed bonds. Stocks and bonds fell together. The classic mix had no shelter. That is a wake-up call. We need to think wider about diversification.
“Any combination of stocks and bonds that you had went down together in unison.”
That line still hits. It captures the core lesson. Balance needs more than two levers when inflation drives markets. Alternatives are not a luxury. They fill a missing role. The key is to choose tools with a purpose and fit them into a plan with discipline.
What I’m Watching Now
I track four signposts to guide positioning:
- Inflation trend: Headline and core readings, plus sticky service prices.
- Policy path: Central bank guidance and the pace of balance sheet changes.
- Yield curve shape: It hints at growth risks and pressure on duration.
- Credit spreads: The price of risk in the system as conditions tighten or ease.
These signals help me adjust the mix within the sleeve. If policy is tight and inflation is still firm, I lean more on trend and inflation hedges. If inflation cools and growth slows, I may shift toward quality bonds and reduce cyclical exposures. The goal is not to outguess each print. It is to keep the portfolio ready for a range of paths.
A Plan You Can Stick With
Investing is not about perfect calls. It is about building a plan you can live with through rough years. In 2022, it was tested on many people. The message from that test is clear. A portfolio built only on stocks and core bonds can struggle when inflation shocks hit. That does not mean you abandon the basics. It means you add innovative components that do different jobs.
As a CFP and CIMA, and as the CEO of LifeGoal Wealth Advisors, I build with that in mind. I aim for simple, clear roles and steady rules. I want clients to understand why each sleeve exists and how it should behave. That clarity is what helps you hold the line when the next shock arrives.
Rising rates were the worst force for bonds. We all felt it. The fix is not a fancy trick. It is broader, purpose-built diversification and plain discipline. Add tools that can handle inflation and rate moves. Size them right. Rebalance. Keep your eyes on the signposts.
Do this, and your plan will be better prepared for the next challenging year.
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Why did bonds drop so much in 2022?
Bond prices move opposite yields. Inflation jumped, and policy rates rose fast, so yields shot higher. Existing bonds with lower coupons fell to match new, higher-yield bonds, driving broad losses.
Q: Does a 60/40 portfolio still make sense?
It can still work over long periods, but it struggled during the selloff driven by inflation. Adding a modest sleeve of inflation-aware and trend strategies can improve balance in those conditions.
Q: What are simple ways to add alternatives without overhauling everything?
Consider a small mix of TIPS, short-duration bonds, a broad commodity fund, and a managed futures fund. Keep sizing modest, watch fees, and rebalance on a set schedule.
