Why Bitcoin is Not Fully Regulated in the United States

Updated on January 24th, 2022
bitcoin

A Cryptocoins News article reported on a current legal battle being duked out in a California court illustrates just some of the many challenges involved in fully regulating Bitcoin and the entire cryptocurrency system. It sheds light on the number of legal concerns associated with this digital currency.

This is along with the other main issue of no standardized set of regulations across countries even though the altcoins are being used across territories to pay for goods and services.

Disagreements About Bitcoin’s Role

Is it a commodity or a currency? Can it be both or change roles based on the type of transaction? It’s difficult to regulate something where there has yet to be agreement on exactly what role it plays.

For example, the California case involved HashFast Technologies, a company that paid for services using Bitcoin and was trying to sue to recover that currency after it had been paid to a physician. The ruling by the bankruptcy court judge concluded that cryptocurrency is not the same as U.S. currency but was actually considered to be “intangible personal property.”

This has proved to be a test on what have been termed “clawback” actions, which are intended to recover money that has been disbursed. As part of the judgment, however, the judge did not rule on the ownership issue and will decide later if the physician must return the Bitcoin or an equivalent in U.S. currency.

Another argument that had yet to be decided is the exact value of the Bitcoin as it fluctuates. The difference in repayment could be as $1 million if the decision is made that it is a currency instead of a commodity. It would seem that this would need to be first determined in order to properly regulate cryptocurrency.

This bankruptcy ruling also brings up another issue, which is that bankruptcy code and most likely many other legal codes have not been written with Bitcoin in mind. Therefore, before regulating cryptocurrency, many codes would need to be updated to reflect this new way of conducting transactions and involve making specific decisions as to how it should be treated.

Different Countries, Different Regulations

It’s also difficult to regulate Bitcoin when, in actual fact, regulations vary from country to country. The only similarity may very well be those countries where cryptocurrency is banned or restricted. The issue of how it is classified also comes up again when looking at a global view of Bitcoin.

In an Investopedia article, a roundup of countries illustrates some of the varied regulations related to cryptocurrency.

Here are some examples of the different bitcoin regulations:

  • Australia wants to tax cryptocurrency like other commercial transactions but is also cautious after security concerns from losses in 2013.
  • Brazil has enacted a law about electronic currencies and payment systems, leading the way in evolving its regulations.
  • Canada would like to tax Bitcoin but it is currently not recognized as legal tender so as no legal recognition.
  • China restricts its use and does allow financial institutions to conduct any transactions using Bitcoin.
  • The European Union has spent time debating the issue and has found some ways to tie a legal basis for Bitcoin to its existing laws, but the European Banking Authority is still against it until it becomes regulated.
  • Finland has created specific instructions on how it can be used. It also has made any gains from these transactions subject to capital gains tax.
  • India has shut down the country’s largest Bitcoin trading platform and currently has no regulatory framework for cryptocurrency.
  • Russia restricts the use of Bitcoin and is concerned over its potential for use in money laundering or terrorist activities.
  • The UK does not currently regulate cryptocurrency but does subject profits or losses on Bitcoin trading to capital gains tax while VAT is applied to any goods that are sold in exchange for this digital currency.

Many more countries are in similar places to these listed here, but these examples illustrate just how far apart the world is on reaching some type of agreement on regulations of Bitcoin.

Future Perspectives on Full Regulation for Cryptocurrency

Those that see the true potential of Bitcoin are focused on getting others, including international and national government bodies, banking and financial institutions, court systems, business and consumers, to understand as well. According to an article in The Guardian, they are trying to put past issues behind them, such as the high-profile criminal prosecutions of two Bitcoin entrepreneurs, the suspension of trading on the second-largest Bitcoin exchange, and volatile pricing, and move forward with a focus on finding common regulatory ground to stimulate wider adoption.

Therefore, regulatory measures need to focus on security, price stabilization, and a position for Bitcoin (currency versus commodity) in order to revise existing laws and create new ones that govern this disruptive transaction process. Clearly, cooperation among countries and the associated governing bodies will need to happen with many debates and sessions that end in regulatory resolution for cryptocurrencies.

John Rampton

John Rampton

John Rampton is an entrepreneur and connector. When he was 23 years old while attending the University of Utah he was hurt in a construction accident. His leg was snapped in half. He was told by 13 doctors he would never walk again. Over the next 12 months he had several surgeries, stem cell injections and learned how to walk again. During this time he studied and mastered how to make money work for you, not against you. He has since taught thousands through books, courses and written over 5000 articles online about finance, entrepreneurship and productivity. He has been recognized as the Top Online Influencers in the World by Entrepreneur Magazine, Finance Expert by Time and Annuity Expert by Nasdaq. He is the Founder and CEO of Due.

About Due

Due makes it easier to retire on your terms. We give you a realistic view on exactly where you’re at financially so when you retire you know how much money you’ll get each month. Get started today.
Categories

Due Fact-Checking Standards and Processes

To ensure we’re putting out the highest content standards, we sought out the help of certified financial experts and accredited individuals to verify our advice. We also rely on them for the most up to date information and data to make sure our in-depth research has the facts right, for today… Not yesterday. Our financial expert review board allows our readers to not only trust the information they are reading but to act on it as well. Most of our authors are CFP (Certified Financial Planners) or CRPC (Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor) certified and all have college degrees. Learn more about annuities, retirement advice and take the correct steps towards financial freedom and knowing exactly where you stand today. Learn everything about our top-notch financial expert reviews below… Learn More