Search
Close this search box.

Table of Contents

Naked Shorting



Definition

Naked shorting refers to the illegal practice of selling short a financial security without actually borrowing or owning the shares. Traders engage in naked shorting to profit from anticipated price declines without having to deliver the shares to buyers. This practice can lead to market manipulation, as it allows traders to artificially increase the supply of shares, putting downward pressure on the security’s price.

Phonetic

The phonetic spelling of “Naked Shorting” using the International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) is:ˈneɪkɪd ˈʃɔrtɪŋ

Key Takeaways

  1. Naked shorting is an illegal practice where a person or company sells shares of a stock that they do not actually own, with the intention of buying them back at a lower price to make a profit.
  2. It can have negative consequences for the targeted stock, as it artificially increases selling pressure and lowers the stock’s value, potentially leading to financial harm for legitimate investors.
  3. Regulatory authorities, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission, have implemented regulations to prevent naked shorting and work to enforce these rules to protect investors and maintain the integrity of financial markets.

Importance

Naked shorting is an important business/finance term because it refers to an illegal practice where short sellers sell shares they haven’t borrowed, with no intention of delivering those shares to the buyer, which often leads to potential market manipulation. This controversial strategy often exacerbates price declines in targeted stocks, causing artificial volatility, and harms the businesses’ value and investor confidence. As a result, regulatory actions have been taken by authorities such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to curb this malicious activity, ensuring fair market practices and protecting the integrity of financial markets.

Explanation

Naked shorting, an advanced trading strategy, is employed by investors who speculate that a stock’s price will decline in the future. Typically, a trader might borrow shares in a stock and sell them short, betting that the price will fall and they can subsequently buy the shares back at a lower cost to return to the lender, thus making a profit from the price difference. However, naked shorting circumvents the traditional short-selling process by not actually borrowing the shares or even ensuring their availability. This means the trader sells shares they neither own nor have arranged to borrow. Naked shorting can be utilized for various reasons, but primarily serves as a method of exerting downward pressure on a stock’s price or creating the appearance of increased trading activity to influence market sentiment. While naked shorting has the potential to generate substantial profits for investors, it is important to recognize that this practice comes with a fair share of risks and ethical concerns. The primary risk lies in its potential to cause artificial price manipulation, with traders selling large volumes of non-existent shares, which can lead to panic selling and unwarranted price drops. As a result, many financial regulators, including those in the United States, have taken measures to curb naked shorting by enacting stricter rules surrounding the borrowing and lending of securities. Despite its limited use and legal restrictions, naked shorting remains a contentious issue within the financial world, and understanding its purpose and applications can help provide insight into broader market forces and trends.

Examples

Naked shorting, also known as naked short selling, is an illegal practice in which investors sell shares of stock they do not own, have not borrowed, and have not ensured they can borrow. Here are three real-world examples of naked shorting: 1. Overstock.com case (2007)In 2007, Overstock.com filed a lawsuit against several hedge funds and brokerage firms, accusing them of naked short selling. The company claimed that the defendants were conspiring to manipulate the market by engaging in naked shorting. They alleged that this manipulation depressed the company’s stock price, causing harm to their business. In 2010, Overstock.com reached a settlement with the brokerage firm Goldman Sachs, though specific details of the settlement remain undisclosed. 2. Porsche and Volkswagen case (2008)During the 2008 financial crisis, German automaker Porsche was in the process of acquiring a majority stake in Volkswagen. Hedge funds and other investors who were short-selling Volkswagen shares ended up in a short squeeze when Porsche revealed that it held a much larger stake in Volkswagen than was previously disclosed. Many short sellers were assumed to have engaged in naked shorting, leading to a sharp rise in Volkswagen’s share price. At one point, Volkswagen briefly became the most valuable company in the world due to this short squeeze. Eventually, market regulators tightened the regulation on short selling to curb such behavior. 3. Lehman Brothers case (2008)Lehman Brothers, a global financial services firm, filed for bankruptcy in September 2008, contributing to the global financial crisis. Prior to their collapse, there were numerous instances of suspicious trading activity involving Lehman Brothers’ stock. This activity included significant volumes of failed trades, suggesting that naked short selling may have played a role in driving down the company’s share price. Although naked shorting has not been proven conclusively in this case, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) adopted new rules in the aftermath to curb naked short selling and improve transparency in the markets.

Frequently Asked Questions(FAQ)

What is Naked Shorting?
Naked shorting is an illegal trading practice where a trader or investor sells shares of a stock that they have not borrowed or do not own. This practice essentially allows the trader to sell something they don’t possess, creating an artificial supply and potentially manipulating the stock’s price.
How does Naked Shorting differ from Short Selling?
In short selling, a trader borrows shares of a stock they believe will lose value, sells them at the current market price, and then aims to buy them back at a lower price to return to the lender. The profit is the difference between the selling price and buying price, minus fees. Naked shorting skips the step of borrowing shares, so the trader never actually possesses or owns the shares they sell.
Is Naked Shorting legal?
No, naked shorting is illegal in most countries, as it can lead to market manipulation and false information about a company’s value. Regulatory authorities, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States, have imposed strict rules and penalties to prevent and punish naked shorting.
How does Naked Shorting affect the market?
Naked shorting can have negative effects on the market, as it can manipulate stock prices and distort the overall supply and demand for a security. This can harm investors and exacerbate downward price trends. Additionally, naked shorting may cause reputational damage to the companies whose stocks are targeted, as it creates false impressions of their financial health.
How can Naked Shorting be detected?
Naked shorting can be difficult to detect, as it often occurs in the intricacies of the stock trading process. However, regulatory authorities track stock borrowing and settlement data to identify suspicious trading patterns and investigate potential cases of naked shorting. Increased transparency and improved methods of tracking borrowed shares can help prevent this practice.
What are the penalties for Naked Shorting?
The penalties for naked shorting vary depending on the jurisdiction, but they may include substantial fines, trading restrictions, and even criminal charges. The SEC, for example, has the authority to freeze assets and pursue legal action against individuals and firms involved in naked shorting.

Related Finance Terms

Sources for More Information


About Our Editorial Process

At Due, we are dedicated to providing simple money and retirement advice that can make a big impact in your life. Our team closely follows market shifts and deeply understands how to build REAL wealth. All of our articles undergo thorough editing and review by financial experts, ensuring you get reliable and credible money advice.

We partner with leading publications, such as Nasdaq, The Globe and Mail, Entrepreneur, and more, to provide insights on retirement, current markets, and more.

We also host a financial glossary of over 7000 money/investing terms to help you learn more about how to take control of your finances.

View our editorial process

About Our Journalists

Our journalists are not just trusted, certified financial advisers. They are experienced and leading influencers in the financial realm, trusted by millions to provide advice about money. We handpick the best of the best, so you get advice from real experts. Our goal is to educate and inform, NOT to be a ‘stock-picker’ or ‘market-caller.’ 

Why listen to what we have to say?

While Due does not know how to predict the market in the short-term, our team of experts DOES know how you can make smart financial decisions to plan for retirement in the long-term.

View our expert review board

About Due

Due makes it easier to retire on your terms. We give you a realistic view on exactly where you’re at financially so when you retire you know how much money you’ll get each month. Get started today.

Due Fact-Checking Standards and Processes

To ensure we’re putting out the highest content standards, we sought out the help of certified financial experts and accredited individuals to verify our advice. We also rely on them for the most up to date information and data to make sure our in-depth research has the facts right, for today… Not yesterday. Our financial expert review board allows our readers to not only trust the information they are reading but to act on it as well. Most of our authors are CFP (Certified Financial Planners) or CRPC (Chartered Retirement Planning Counselor) certified and all have college degrees. Learn more about annuities, retirement advice and take the correct steps towards financial freedom and knowing exactly where you stand today. Learn everything about our top-notch financial expert reviews below… Learn More