With such a daunting tax code, many financial professionals recommend paying a tax pro to prepare tax returns. It’s so easy to miss a deduction or worse, make a mistake. Due to ease of use, software programs like TurboTax and H&R Block have gained popularity in recent years. Though cheaper, it’s still quite the time commitment and many are left wondering whether they are leaving money on the table. These factors lead many to fork over some cash in exchange for a professionally prepared filing. Once that decision is made, who do you choose? Your choices are normally your senior citizen neighbor who is doing them for $50, a higher end accounting firm, or an H&R Block type franchise. For the financially untrained, this is not an easy decision. We’d like to share some tips on how and why you should choose a tax professional.

Why pay a tax preparer? I can do it myself!

Anyone can answer the multiple choice questions posed by aforementioned software, which then spits out some numbers on a form. The reason you should pay a tax preparer is to take an aggressive position. I’m not saying you should embellish or lie on your return, far from it. I’m merely suggesting to take advantage of the many grey areas our great tax code has to offer. A good tax guy will know what issues are trending in the eyes of the IRS. They best way to explain this is that certain areas aren’t even known or enforced as other areas. You’d never know this information if you’re preparing merely one tax return year.   

Whether aggressive or conservative, every tax position should be substantiated with a strong opinion/reasoning for doing so. Sure! You can do it yourself but you don’t have a client base to draw experience from. For example, if none of your clients have received a noticed to check the price regarding their home office deduction in 20 years of practice, you may be able to conclude the IRS isn’t focusing their resources on that issue. On the contrary, if you had 6 clients receive notices about a specific deduction or issue, you’ll need a stronger opinion than normal before sending out your paperwork.

Bottom line is: Don’t hire a number inputter, hire an experienced professional!

Referrals

The best place to start is to ask your peers who they file their return with. The important thing to know is why they are happy with the service provided. If they reply “because they gave me a large refund,” that’s a bad answer. Don’t EVER judge an accountant by who can give you a bigger refund! Sound, honest financial practices will sometimes say a bigger refund is giving the government an interest free loan they didn’t apply for. Judge their quality of work by timeliness, availability for questions, and detail they put into your return. One indicator of detail is by the questions they ask you. Then — go with your gut feeling!  

Avoid national tax franchises

Honestly, I don’t want to make this a bashing session on H&R Block or Jackson Hewitt, because I’ve used both and it was okay. The truth is that there aren’t too many barriers to entry in becoming a tax preparer. Companies like these put their employees through a quick training course and their on your way. That’s not what you want. Especially as your taxes become more complicated, you don’t want your tax return to be somebody’s side hustle. Make sure the town plumber isn’t moonlighting as your tax accountant. Plumbers deserve as much respect as the next guy but they aren’t hired for their knowledge of Form 1040. H&R Block’s average tax return fee was $273 as of 2014. Seems like an awful lot to pay for someone who doesn’t do this full time.    

Experience

Ideally, you’d want your accountant to have some public accounting experience. Public accounting is typically known as a CPA firm. If you go with this choice, you almost certainly will pay a higher fee but it will be worth it. The penalties and interest of a misstated return can be very costly, not to mention stressful. One workaround is to look for and hire someone who has recently left the tax industry for their new freelance tax job. (Same field.) There’s a chance these individuals may have a lower fee because they won’t have employees or rent to pay. Most likely, they’ll be doing returns out of their house.  

Make sure the tax preparation person was on the tax side of the business for at least 3 years. I say this because many accountants have never touched the sort of tax return you need, as their career may have been specialized in a different area of accounting. Three years is enough time for them to have seen hundreds of clients. Unless you have some sort of complicated business, they’ll be able to handle what you’re bringing to the table.  

If you’re a business owner, you’ll want to verify that they have some experience dealing with your industry. For instance, restaurants and manufacturing type establishments may require specialized knowledge. Service industries may not need as much extra tax knowledge because many areas in service have clear-cut allowable deductions, possibly making their financial statements less complicated in some areas (not to say they are easy by any stretch of the imagination).

Now you know how to pick a winner! By following the advice above, you’ll steer clear of the basic roadblocks to choosing the right professional. Still — remember — choose wisely!      

Eric Estevez is a freelance writer, blogger, finance coach, and tax accountant. He has been training in the grappling art of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu since 2010, currently holding the rank of Purple Belt. JiuJitsuFinance.com combines his passion and life's work where he teaches you how to do Financial Jiu-Jitsu! The blog focuses on financial literacy, as well as current financial issues for all ages.

Start Getting Paid Today
Due allows you to send money and get paid instantly.
Try Due for free

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This